Comparing Soap-Making Moulds Without the Confusion

by Editorial Team
Assorted soap-making moulds, including silicone loaf moulds, wooden moulds, and plastic cavity moulds, displayed with vibrant handmade soaps and tools, inspired by professional soap-making essentials.

Soap making is a creative and exciting craft, especially when you run a business and want your products to look professional. But picking the right mould can be tricky. Maybe you’re trying to upgrade your moulds or buy new ones but don’t know which ones will work best. Don’t worry—this guide will give you clear examples and tips to help you make the right choice.

Why the Right Soap-Making Mould Matters

Soap moulds aren’t just containers. They shape your soap, make production easier, and help your products stand out. Here’s why the right mould matters:

Larger or better-designed moulds save time and effort. For example, a metal slab mould can make 20 bars in one batch, while a loaf mould makes only 8-10 bars.

Consistent bars build trust with your customers. When all your soaps are the same size and shape, your products look polished and professional.

Unique moulds give your soaps that extra “wow” factor. Seasonal moulds, like hearts for Valentine’s Day, are perfect for special promotions.

The right mould can save you time, impress customers, and make soap making more fun.

Types of Soap-Making Moulds

Here’s a breakdown of the most popular types of moulds. Each one has specific benefits and challenges, so you can find the perfect fit for your needs.

1. Silicone Loaf Moulds

What They Are: Flexible, non-stick moulds that are simple to use and clean. They come in basic loaf shapes and detailed designs.

Pros:

  • Soap pops out easily without breaking or sticking.
  • Perfect for designs with swirls or layers. You can try a rainbow soap with different colours stacked on top of each other.
  • Durable and long-lasting. Good silicone moulds can handle hundreds of batches.
  • Easy to clean—just rinse with warm water.

Cons:

  • Silicone holds heat, so your soap might take longer to set.
  • Larger silicone moulds can bend without a sturdy frame to hold them in place.

Example Use: If you’re making 10-12 bars per batch and want to play with colourful designs, silicone loaf moulds are perfect.

Our Take: Silicone loaf moulds are a great choice for beginners and pros alike. Just remember to get a frame if you’re using a large mould to keep its shape.

2. Wooden Loaf Moulds

What They Are: Sturdy moulds made of wood, ideal for making bigger batches.

Pros:

  • Retain heat, helping your soap set evenly. This is especially helpful for recipes that need a gel phase.
  • Great for making larger batches. A wooden loaf mould can produce 15 bars at a time.
  • Custom sizes are easy to find or make.

Cons:

  • You need a liner (like parchment paper) to prevent soap from sticking to the wood.
  • Wooden moulds need extra care, like occasional oiling, to prevent damage.

Example Use: These are ideal if you’re producing large, consistent batches for wholesale orders.

Our Take: Wooden loaf moulds are reliable for big batches. They need more upkeep but deliver great results.

3. Plastic Cavity Moulds

What They Are: Lightweight, affordable moulds with individual cavities for unique shapes.

Pros:

  • Affordable and easy to replace. You can find a 6-cavity floral mould for around $15.
  • Perfect for seasonal or decorative soaps, like hearts or pumpkins.
  • Easy to store because they’re lightweight.

Cons:

  • Plastic can crack with frequent use or exposure to hot soap.
  • Soap might stick to the mould, so it’s best to use a release spray or chill the soap before unmoulding.

Example Use: Great for creating special-edition soaps for holidays or events.

Our Take: Plastic cavity moulds are fun for creative projects, but they’re not built for heavy-duty use.

4. Metal Slab Moulds

What They Are: Durable moulds that make large slabs of soap, which can be cut into bars.

Pros:

  • High capacity, making them perfect for large production runs. A single slab mould can produce 20-40 bars.
  • Long-lasting and resistant to warping or cracking.
  • Produce clean, sharp-edged bars that look professional.

Cons:

  • More expensive, with prices ranging from $80 to $150.
  • Heavier and harder to move when full.
  • Require liners to prevent sticking.

Example Use: Perfect for businesses needing high-volume production for retail or wholesale.

Our Take: If you’re ready to scale up, metal slab moulds are a smart investment. They’re durable, efficient, and deliver consistent results.

How to Choose the Right Mould

Here’s a simple checklist to help you pick the best mould:

  • Batch Size: Small batches? Go with silicone or plastic. Large batches? Wooden or metal moulds are better.
  • Design: Want simple shapes? Use loaf or slab moulds. Want decorative designs? Pick cavity moulds.
  • Material: Silicone is easy to use, wood is sturdy, and metal is long-lasting. Choose what suits your needs.
  • Budget: If you’re starting out, silicone or plastic is affordable. For serious production, invest in wood or metal.
  • Ease of Use: Silicone is low-maintenance. Wooden and metal moulds take a bit more prep.

Tips for Using Soap-Making Moulds

  1. Clean and prepare your mould before every use.
  2. Use liners for wooden and metal moulds to prevent sticking.
  3. Let your soap fully set before unmoulding to avoid cracks or damage.
  4. Test small batches first when trying a new mould.
  5. Rotate your moulds to extend their lifespan.

FAQ: Common Questions About Soap-Making Moulds

Q: How do I prevent soap from sticking to the mould?

  • For wooden and metal moulds, use a liner like parchment paper. For silicone or plastic, you can lightly spray with a release agent or chill the soap before unmoulding.

Q: What’s the best mould for beginners?

  • Silicone loaf moulds are a great starting point. They’re easy to use, clean, and versatile for small batches.

Q: How long should soap stay in the mould?

  • It depends on the recipe, but most soaps need 24-48 hours to set before unmoulding. If it’s still soft, give it more time.

Q: Can I reuse liners for wooden moulds?

  • Yes, but only if they’re in good condition. Wrinkled or torn liners can affect the shape of your soap.

Q: How do I choose the right size mould?

  • Consider how many bars you want per batch. A small silicone loaf mould makes about 10-12 bars, while a large slab mould can make up to 40.

Q: Are plastic moulds durable?

  • Plastic moulds are lightweight and affordable but not ideal for heavy use. They can crack over time, especially with hot soap.

What’s Next for Village Craft & Candle

At Village Craft & Candle, we know how important the right tools are for soap makers. While we don’t carry soap-making moulds yet, we’re working on it! Soon, we’ll offer a curated selection of moulds to support your craft. In the meantime, check out our fragrances, colours, and other supplies to take your soap-making to the next level.

Choosing the right soap-making mould doesn’t have to be complicated. With these examples and tips, you’re ready to create soaps that look amazing and meet your business needs. 

Stay tuned for updates from Village Craft & Candle, and happy soap making!

Important Disclaimer:
Fragrance Oils and Health Products Our fragrance oils are intended for external use in candles, diffusers, and some cosmetic applications. They are not to be ingested, inhaled, or applied directly to skin without proper dilution. Health Canada requires a Natural Product Number (NPN) for the sale of any product making health claims or intended for therapeutic use. It is your responsibility to ensure your final product formulation complies with all applicable regulations and obtains the necessary NPN certification before sale.

Fragrance oils, when incorporated into health products, may require additional safety testing to ensure their suitability and interaction with other ingredients. We strongly recommend conducting independent testing by a qualified laboratory to confirm the safety and efficacy of your final product formulation. By purchasing this product, you agree to assume all responsibility for its proper use and application. We shall not be held liable for any misuse, claims, or damages resulting from the use of this fragrance oil in a health product.

Back to Blog